.
/ The GW Bush administration and its aftermath / The Dark Side / The Decline /
/ The Fall / The Greens / Industrialism / KOYAANISQATSI / Liberalism /
/ Perspectives / Proposals and Recommendations / Suggestions for Greener Living / "Summations" /
/ Taking Action / Ten Key Values of the Greens /


/ Progress Report /



- PAGE IS UNDER CONSTRUCTION SEP 08

Why we fight --

This site was begun during the late Clinton administration (approximately 1998), inspired by the conviction that politics and society in the USA were headed in the wrong direction.

So, ten years on, how are we doing?

(If you want to just skip straight to my assessment without discussion, click here.)



My ideal government and society would be a"Classical Liberal Green" one, and notably including small government and emphasis on human and civil rights. ( - N.b. that "Classical Liberal" does not mean "liberal" in the contemporary talk-show host sense; it is actually more-or-less "classical conservatism". Yeah, everybody else finds that confusing and annoying, too.)

(A very quick summary of my ideal government and society is that it is "the opposite of fascism" or "regressivism", along with an emphasis on ecological concerns if you feel that such emphasis would not otherwise be included.)


A few schematics from sources that I was reading when I created this site,
with my observations on developments.


Click to jump to that section




- A list of Ten Green Values
as formulated in 1984
by Charlene Spretnak and the
Platform Working Group
of the Green Party of California.
- The key foundations of "the modern industrial economy"
from Eat The Rich by P. J. O'Rourke.
.
.
- The "Elements of Liberalism"
from Liberalism, by L. Hobhouse.
.
.



- A list of Ten Green Values
as formulated in 1984 by Charlene Spretnak and the Platform Working Group of the Green Party of California.


  • Ecological Wisdom
    The Earth's population has gone from something under six billion in 1998 to about six and a half billion in 2008, accompanied by a strong increase in utilization of resources per person (the "Western standard of living" model).

    As a handy example --
    Lifelines from Our Past
    by L.S. Stavrianos
    Online. Page 177 here, Page 178 here.
    "Mao's successor Deng Xiaoping reversed China's priorities (beginning in the 1980s and ongoing), placing expertness before redness ["being red" defined elsewhere in the text as being "a 'comrade' who did manual as well as intellectual work, and who focussed on serving society rather than self"]. Government slogans no longer called on the people to "Fight Self"; rather, they assured citizens that "To Get Rich Is Glorious." Consumer expectations rose accordingly --from the "big four" (bicycle, sewing machine, radio, and watch) to the "big six" (color TV, washing machine, radio-cassette player, refrigerator, electric fan, and motorcycle) and most recently to the "eight big things" comprising the "big six" plus modern furniture and a camera."

    And of course, now add to the list a cellphone, computer/Internet, for the ambitious a car ...

    In Riding the Iron Rooster (p 167), Paul Theroux quotes the 1986 short story "The Wind on the Plateau" by Wang Meng:
    "He wanted video equipment, a musical door-chime, a motorcycle and a rubber dinghy. Why not go out and get an air-conditioner made in Australia?"
    Middle America comes to China, indeed.
    Links are mine - ed.
    - A page on this site on / China /
    -- Not only do we now have six and a half billion people, but they're all saying, "Wait a minute, the Americans all have a house and a car and a TV and a home entertainment system and nice clothes and a fridge and a washing machine and vacations in Hawaii -- I want all those things too."

    - The issue of global warming aka "global climate change" has exploded into the public consciousness. The actions taken to reduce it have been almost nil. It seems likely to me that very little will be done to mitigate this in the foreseeable future. The best outcome that I can forsee is large-scale ecological damage; coastal flooding with displacement of half a billion or a billion people and accompanying social unrest, hunger, health problems, and misery; worldwide increase in drought, severe rainfall with flooding, hurricanes, etc; problems with food production. I don't think that significantly worse outcomes can be ruled out.

    - On the animal rights and welfare front, here's
    Activism and Veganism Reconsidered: Personal Thoughts at the New Millennium
    (Was: Veganism: The Path to Animal Liberation), by Matt Ball
    "During the time the AR (Animal Rights) movement has been visible in the U.S. (since ~1980), AR activists have stopped some abuses, received media attention, and become a fixture of pop culture. Yet after two decades, with hundreds of millions of dollars spent and possibly a similar number of hours of work devoted, almost twice as many animals will be killed in the U.S. this year (2000, as far as I can tell) as were killed in 1980."
    I don't think that there will have been any improvement in these numbers in the USA since 2000, and globally, more people are probably eating more meat and using more animal products than ever before in history.

  • Grassroots Democracy
    Democracy has obviously taken a severe beating in the USA.

    machine voting systems have proven very unreliable, and have been controlled (and kept secret by) private companies.

  • Social Justice and Personal Responsibility

  • Nonviolence
    The USA:
      - has initiated two unjust wars (against Afghanistan and Iraq); directly killed thousands of civilians, including women, children, and the elderly

      - additionally has directly caused thousands of "excess deaths" of civilian men, women, and children due to civil unrest, disruption of infrastructure, etc

      - has imprisoned and tortured hundreds or thousands (obviously enough, the numbers are kept secret), often on very flimsy pretexts

      - has continued to build astronomically expensive high-tech, capital-intensive, and often fuel-thirsty weapons systems (aircraft carriers, new jet fighter aircraft, nuclear ballistic missiles) of very questionable utility (unless we specifically do want to cause Armageddon).

      - has developed various "crowd control" technologies such as the microwave-based "Active Denial System" (aka by more informal journalists "ray gun"), which causes "intolerable pain"

      - has seen the explosive growth of "private military companies" providing (per SourceWatch)
      "risk advisory, training of local forces, armed site security, cash transport, intelligence services, workplace and building security, war zone security needs, weapons procurement, personnel and budget vetting, armed support, air support, logistical support, maritime security, cyber security, weapons destruction, prisons, surveillance, psychological warfare, propaganda tactics, covert operations, close protection and investigations", often in combat zomes, and which are specifically exempt from domestic and international laws regulating military forces.

  • Decentralization
    "unitary executive"

  • Community Based Economics
    The power of private corporations has continued to grow.

  • Feminism
    I'm a strong feminist, but I don't worry about this issue much. The progress of feminism in the USA and worldwide over the last ten years has been uneven, and I'd certainly like to see faster progress to smooth out the rough bits, but I think overall things have moved in the right direction.

    Additionally, as I write this in September 2008 it seems entirely likely that Sarah Palin will become Vice President of the U.S. -- and further will become President due to the death or medical incapacity of John McCain. I personally feel that Palin is one of the worst candidates for the Executive branch of the U.S. government to come along in quite a while, but that has nothing to do with her gender, and obviously the fact that she is seriously considered for this position is evidence of the strength of feminism.

  • Respect for Diversity
    Some good news, some bad news.

    - The traditional racial and ethnic antagonisms in the USA seem to have cooled during the last decadebut have been replaced by fear and hatred of Muslims and Arabs, and to a lesser extent suspicion of Latino immigration. The educational and economic status of African-Americans remains very bad by comparison with European-Americans.

    - On the brighter side, acceptance of GLBT and "queer" persons has steadily moved further into the mainstream.

  • Global Responsibility

  • Sustainability
    Some good news, some bad news, with I think the latter considerably outweighing the former. On the good side, public awareness of the importance of sustainability is considerably stronger. On the bad side, most people are still not taking any significant steps to translate the idea of sustainability into action, and government and big business continue to largely ignore (and indeed often to block) useful change.

    The population increase noted above has made an already very serious problem that much worse.



  • - The key foundations of "the modern industrial economy"
    from Eat The Rich by P. J. O'Rourke.


  • Hard Work
    - There are obviously still millions of Americans who embody the traditional "Puritan" work ethic, and they may be found at all levels of the workforce, from the 80-hour-a-week top executive to the 80-hour-a-week two- or three-jobs manual laborer.

  • Education
    - The U.S. primary and secondary school system exhibits very serious problems. It's "okay", but a great many people wonder why it isn't a lot better. I personally blame the fixation of young people on television and other "media culture": computer games, pop music, low-brow movies, etc, etc. -- as well as the acceptance by their elders of such fixation.
    "Only the vigilant can maintain their liberties, and only those who are constantly and intelligently on the spot can hope to govern themselves effectively by democratic procedures. A society, most of whose members spend a great deal of their time not on the spot, not here and now (or) in the calculable future, but somewhere else, in the irrelevant other worlds of sport and soap opera, of mythology and metaphysical fantasy, will find it hard to resist the encroachments of those who would manipulate and control it."

    Propaganda in a democratic society
    by Aldous Huxley
    "... in Huxley's vision (Brave New World), no Big Brother is required to deprive people of their autonomy, maturity, and history. As he saw it, people will come to love their oppression, to adore the technologies that undo their capacities to think.

    What Orwell feared were those who would ban books. What Huxley feared was that there would be no reason to ban a book, for there would be no one who wanted to read one."
    Amusing Ourselves to Death : Public Discourse in the Age of Show Business
    by Neil Postman
    page vii

  • Responsibility

  • Property Rights
    Property rights have been eroded in the USA over the last few decades: conservatives point to "regulatory takings', civil libertarians to "asset forfeiture" as practiced in the War on Drugs.

  • Rule of Law
    From Wikipedia -
    "The rule of law, in its most basic form, is the principle that no one is above the law and that everyone must abide by the law. Thomas Paine stated in his pamphlet Common Sense (1776): "For as in absolute governments the king is law, so in free countries the law ought to be king; and there ought to be no other." ...

    Perhaps the most important application of the rule of law is the principle that governmental authority is legitimately exercised only in accordance with written, publicly disclosed laws adopted and enforced in accordance with established procedural steps that are referred to as due process. The principle is intended to be a safeguard against arbitrary governance, whether by a totalitarian leader or by mob rule. Thus, the rule of law is hostile both to dictatorship and to anarchy."

  • Democratic Government
    - Discussed above under "Grassroots Democracy"




  • - The "Elements of Liberalism"
    from Liberalism, by L. Hobhouse.

  • Civil Liberty

    - The Rule of Law and freedom from arbitrary harassment by the agents of the State
    Has been severely damaged over the last ten years. We won't have to go much further before "arbitrary harassment by the agents of the State" becomes the rule rather than the exception.


  • Fiscal Liberty

    - Freedom from arbitrary taxation; a system of taxation generated by a legislative - ideally democratic - process.
    The tax system in the USA could be a lot worse, but it could be a lot better, too. As in many societies, a major problem is that wealthy individuals and corporations receive tax breaks. Most discussions of tax revision over the last few years have been either smoke-and-mirrors misdirection, or at the least substantially ineffective.


  • Personal Libertyor Civil Rights


  • Social Liberty, broadly, freeedom from nonmeritocratic barriers


  • Economic Liberty or free trade


  • Domestic Liberty

    - freedom from interference by the State in the affairs of the family.


  • Local, Racial, and National Liberty

    - general applicability of laws; minimizing of "special cases"


  • International LibertyPacifism, freedom from the exercise of military power


  • Political Liberty and Popular Sovereignty. Democracy




  • keyword search bushlegacy bushl goplegacy gopl gwblegacy gwbl worstpresident .......

    A Digression on the GW Bush Years:
    JAN 2009


    As I read back over many of the sources on this site from the years of the GW Bush administation, I'm struck by the real fear expressed in many of them: of the institution of a dictatorship in the USA, of the use of nuclear weapons in the Middle East, etc.

    I hope that as you're reading this in 2010 or 2014 or whatever, these fears seem silly and overwrought to you (rather than simply premature), but at the time they were real and seemed to have solid justification (the track record of the GW Bush administration would seem to indicate that more evidence of venality will have come to light by the time you read this.)

    So, these things did not actually come to pass, however, I don't think that that in any way means that they weren't plausible possibilities. There were solid reasons to believe that they might happen. They didn't happen. No one seriously believes that they can't happen. Keep fighting to ensure that they don't happen.




    .



    The bottom line to all this is

    We are losing, and losing big.






    - Pages on this site on

    / Suggestions for Greener Living /

    / Taking Action /